If you’ve ever started planning a vacation, chances are you’ve looked at Costco Travel. I hear this question all the time from friends, family, and clients:
“Is Costco Travel better than using a travel agent?”
The honest answer is that both can be good, but they serve very different types of travelers. The best choice depends on how you like to plan, how much support you want, and what kind of trip you’re taking.
As a travel advisor who plans everything from cruises and all-inclusive resorts to Disney and international trips, here’s a real, honest breakdown to help you decide what’s right for you.
What Is Costco Travel?
Costco Travel is an online booking platform available to Costco members. They offer vacation packages, cruises, hotels, rental cars, and sometimes extras like resort credits or Costco Cash Cards.
Many travelers like Costco Travel because:
- Pricing is bundled and easy to see upfront
- You can book online quickly
- Costco is a trusted brand
- Some packages include added perks
Costco Travel works best for simple, straightforward trips, especially when you already know what destination, resort, or cruise you want and feel comfortable managing the details yourself.
What Does a Travel Agent Do?
A travel agent is not just a booking website. We are planners, researchers, problem solvers, and advocates.
When you work with a travel agent, you get:
- Personalized recommendations based on your travel style, budget, and needs
- Help choosing the right destination, resort, ship, or itinerary
- Guidance on timing, pricing, and best-value options
- Assistance with excursions, transfers, dining, and special requests
- Support before, during, and after your trip
Instead of clicking buttons and hoping for the best, you have a real person who understands your trip and is there if something changes.
Pricing: Is Costco Travel Always Cheaper?
This is one of the biggest misconceptions in travel.
Costco Travel often has competitive pricing, especially on cruises and bundled resort packages. Sometimes their price is lower. Sometimes it’s the same. And sometimes it’s higher once you compare what is actually included.
What many travelers don’t realize is that travel agents often have access to:
- Contracted or agency-only rates
- Group pricing
- Special promotions negotiated directly with suppliers
- Added perks that do not increase the base price
So while the price you see online might look appealing, it doesn’t always reflect the full value of the trip.
Extra Perks and Bonuses: A Big Advantage of Using a Travel Agent
This is where working with a travel agent can really stand out.
In addition to planning and support, travel agents can sometimes include extra perks and bonuses such as:
- Onboard credit on cruises
- Specialty dining or drink credits
- Reduced deposits or flexible payment options
- Room or cabin upgrades when available
- Resort or spa credits
- Exclusive agency promotions or limited-time bonuses
Many times, the base cost is the same, but the travel agent booking comes with more added value, which is something my clients really appreciate.
Customization vs. Convenience
Costco Travel
Costco Travel is great if you want:
- A pre-built package (you either want it or don’t, nothing is tailored to you)
- Minimal decision making
- A quick, online booking experience
However, customization is limited. Adjusting flights, mixing resorts, adding specific excursions, or tailoring a trip to special needs can be more restrictive.
Travel Agent
A travel agent shines when:
- You want a trip built specifically for you
- You have kids, multiple travelers, or special considerations
- You want help comparing multiple options
- You don’t want to spend hours researching
- You simply want to make sure you are getting the best deal – travel agents have access to see more back house pricing and can make sure you are getting the best pricing.
This is especially important for families, multi-generational travel, cruises, Disney trips, and travelers with accessibility or sensory needs.
Support When Things Go Wrong
This is something many people don’t think about until it happens.
With Costco Travel:
- You usually contact the supplier directly
- You may wait on hold or be transferred between departments
- You are one booking among many
With a travel agent:
- You contact one person who knows your trip
- We help rebook, adjust, and problem solve
- We advocate for you when plans change
When flights are delayed, excursions are canceled, or something unexpected happens, having a travel agent can make a stressful situation much easier to manage.
Cruises: Where Travel Agents Really Add Value
Cruises are one of the biggest areas where people assume booking direct or through Costco is best.
Here’s what many travelers don’t realize:
- Cruise pricing is set by the cruise line
- The base fare is often the same across platforms
- The difference is in the extras and support
Travel agents frequently have access to:
- Group space with added onboard credit
- Exclusive amenities tied to agency contracts
- Better guidance on cabin selection and ship choice
- Ongoing support if changes are needed
You may pay the same fare but step onboard with more perks and peace of mind.
So… Who Is Better?
The real answer is that it depends on the traveler.
Costco Travel is a good fit if:
- You want a simple, pre-packaged trip (nothing is customized or tailored to your family)
- You are comfortable managing details yourself
- You don’t need much customization or support
A Travel Agent is a better fit if:
- You want personalized planning
- You value guidance and support
- You want access to perks and bonuses
- You want someone to advocate for you
- You are planning a cruise, Disney trip, family vacation, or international travel
My Personal Perspective
Costco Travel can absolutely be a good option, and I am always honest about that with clients. But a travel agent offers something a website never can: personal care, flexibility, and added value.
Between personalized planning, ongoing support, and the potential for extra perks and bonuses, many travelers find that working with a travel agent makes the entire experience easier and more enjoyable.
My goal is simple: to help you travel better, with less stress and more confidence.
Need Help Deciding What’s Right for You?
If you’re not sure whether Costco Travel or a travel agent is the better option for your next trip, I would love to help you figure it out.
📧 Email: Alana.oneal@cruiseplanners.com
My services are always free, and I’m here to help you plan a trip that fits your budget, your lifestyle, and your needs.
Leave a Reply